Skip to content
Powered by Pagefind

Probably Stolen difficulty guide

By the Probably Stolen Wiki editors

Updated

Probably Stolen has four difficulty settings: Cozy, Normal, Hard, and Challenge. The Probably Stolen Game Wiki fan site also gives Cozy, Normal, and Hard alternate names: Price Gouge, Mark Up, and Thin Margins the Probably Stolen Game Wiki fan site. This Probably Stolen difficulty guide lays out the names and explains what the available descriptions say about how difficulty works.

Illustration for a Probably Stolen guide: Corked bottles resting on a wooden rack beside a brass fermenting vat; muted palette with one pale amber accent.
Illustration

How difficulty works in Probably Stolen

Probably Stolen difficulty is presented as a choice among four settings: Cozy, Normal, Hard, and Challenge. The Probably Stolen Game Wiki fan site pairs the first three with the names Price Gouge, Mark Up, and Thin Margins, while Challenge appears without an alternate name on that page. Those labels give players a four-setting list and a set of paired names to recognize.

The names are the concrete information available for describing how difficulty works. The listed descriptions do not attach a specific mechanical change to any setting, so a guide can identify the choices and their naming without assigning effects to them. For a player comparing labels, the useful point is that Cozy, Normal, and Hard each have a paired name in some descriptions, while Challenge is included as the fourth setting.

The naming varies across pages. A Steam community guide uses Easy, Normal, Hard, and Challenge, while the Probably Stolen Game Wiki fan site uses Cozy, Normal, Hard, and Challenge. The difference is most visible in the first setting: one guide calls it Easy, and other descriptions call it Cozy. Treat those as wording differences when comparing the lists, rather than adding a fifth setting.

Entries How it is counted
4Cozy, Normal, Hard, Challenge
4Price Gouge, Mark Up, Thin Margins, Challenge
4Easy, Normal, Hard, Challenge
4Settings named on the fan wiki page
4Settings named in the Steam community guide

What are Cozy and Price Gouge?

Cozy is one of the four difficulty settings, and Price Gouge is the alternate name paired with it on the Probably Stolen Game Wiki fan site. The Probably Stolen gameplay page also pairs Cozy with Price Gouge. A Steam community guide uses Easy for the first setting instead, so players may encounter either Cozy or Easy when reading a four-setting list.

The name pairing helps connect descriptions that use different labels. When a page says Price Gouge (Cozy), it names one setting in two ways; it does not add another setting to the four. The available description gives no specific change to gameplay for Cozy or Price Gouge, so the safe way to use the label is to recognize it as one of the named options.

For a quick comparison with the other choices, keep the Cozy and Price Gouge names together in your notes. That approach preserves the wording used by the Probably Stolen gameplay page and the fan wiki page, while making it easier to recognize the Easy label used in the community guide. The Probably Stolen difficulty list remains four entries whichever label appears first.

What are Normal and Mark Up?

Normal is one of the four difficulty settings, and Mark Up is the alternate name paired with it by the Probably Stolen Game Wiki fan site. The Probably Stolen gameplay page uses the same pairing. The Steam community guide also includes Normal, though it lists no alternate name alongside that setting.

For players checking how difficulty works, Normal is the shared label across these descriptions. Mark Up is useful as a second name to recognize when a list presents the paired wording. No specific mechanical effect is attached to either label in the descriptions here, so this guide does not assign Normal or Mark Up a change beyond identifying the setting.

Probably Stolen difficulty pages can therefore be read consistently by keeping the common label first: Normal is the setting name, and Mark Up is its paired label where that name is shown. That makes the difference between the lists easier to follow without treating the alternate wording as another choice.

What are Hard and Thin Margins?

Hard is one of the four difficulty settings, and Thin Margins is the alternate name paired with it on the Probably Stolen Game Wiki fan site. The Probably Stolen gameplay page gives the same pair. The Steam community guide includes Hard as well, so this setting name appears in both naming styles.

The available descriptions identify Hard and Thin Margins as two labels for one of the four choices. They do not say what the setting changes, and the name alone does not establish a particular effect. For a difficulty guide, the grounded detail is the pairing itself: recognize Hard as the common label and Thin Margins as its alternate wording.

When comparing lists, keep Hard and Thin Margins on the same line rather than counting them separately. The four-setting total stays the same in the descriptions that use the paired name. This is a practical way to read the labels without reading an unlisted mechanic into the phrase Thin Margins.

What are Challenge and Red Ink?

Challenge is the fourth difficulty setting in the lists from the Steam community guide and the Probably Stolen Game Wiki fan site. The Probably Stolen gameplay page pairs Challenge with Red Ink, while the fan wiki's paired list writes Challenge without an alternate name. Red Ink is therefore another label shown for the Challenge setting in one description.

The label difference matters when matching names across pages. A list that says Red Ink (Challenge) still identifies Challenge as one of the four settings, and a list that says only Challenge names that same fourth option without the paired phrase. The descriptions do not attach a specific gameplay change to Challenge or Red Ink.

Players can use Challenge as the shared name when comparing the lists and keep Red Ink as an alternate label where it appears. That reading preserves the wording of the gameplay page while avoiding an extra entry in the count. In this Probably Stolen difficulty guide, the setting is included by name, with no unsupported description of its effect.

Our take on the Probably Stolen difficulty names

Our take is that the four-setting count is the clearest point to carry between the descriptions: each list names four choices. The labels vary, especially for the first setting and for the paired names, but the lists still present four options. That gives players a simple way to compare the wording without mistaking an alternate label for an additional difficulty.

The most complete paired naming in these descriptions is Cozy (Price Gouge), Normal (Mark Up), and Hard (Thin Margins), with Challenge as the fourth setting. The Probably Stolen gameplay page adds Red Ink as a paired name for Challenge. The Steam community guide instead starts with Easy and lists Normal, Hard, and Challenge.

A player looking for how difficulty works should separate two questions: which names appear, and what each setting changes. These descriptions answer the naming question with four entries and alternate labels. They do not give a mechanical explanation for the settings, so a careful difficulty guide should stop at the names rather than promise a particular effect.

For other topics, see the site's pages on starting scenarios, progression, and tips. Those links lead to separate guide topics; the four difficulty labels above remain the scope of this page.

Gallery

Probably Stolen screenshot 1 for the Difficulty guide
Difficulty guide, screenshot 1
Probably Stolen screenshot 2 for the Difficulty guide
Difficulty guide, screenshot 2
Probably Stolen screenshot 3 for the Difficulty guide
Difficulty guide, screenshot 3

Frequently asked questions

How many settings are in Probably Stolen difficulty?

Probably Stolen has four difficulty settings. The lists use Cozy, Normal, Hard, and Challenge, with one Steam community guide using Easy for the first setting.

What are the Probably Stolen difficulty names?

The settings are Cozy, Normal, Hard, and Challenge. Alternate names shown for them are Price Gouge, Mark Up, Thin Margins, and, for Challenge on the gameplay page, Red Ink.

Does Cozy mean the same setting as Easy?

Cozy and Easy are both used as the first name in four-setting lists. The descriptions do not directly explain that naming difference, so use the label shown on the list you are reading.

What does each difficulty setting change?

The descriptions name the four settings and some alternate labels, but they do not state a specific change for each one. This guide can identify the choices without attributing mechanics to their names.

Does the Steam page list Probably Stolen difficulty settings?

The Steam store page does not list difficulty settings. Other pages name four settings, so players looking for the labels can use the Cozy, Normal, Hard, and Challenge list in this Probably Stolen difficulty guide.

Sources