Skip to content
Powered by Pagefind

Probably Stolen butcher Guide

By the Probably Stolen Wiki editors

Updated

The Butcher is a wanted Lower Levels customer who sells discounted meat and scavenged goods, and he returns every seven days if you leave him unreported. The Probably Stolen butcher encounter can offer repeat stock, while reporting him changes the storyline and brings later consequences (Probably Stolen Game character page).

Illustration for a Probably Stolen guide: Illustration about butcher, muted palette with one accent colour.
Illustration

Who is the Probably Stolen butcher?

The Probably Stolen butcher is a wanted Lower Levels customer who sells meat. The Probably Stolen Game character page says he sells stolen meat and returns every seven days if you do not report him. The Probably Stolen Game Wiki fan site also describes him as a wanted Lower Levels customer who sells fresh meat and scavenged goods.

Those details give the encounter two clear parts: a customer visit and a wanted person you can report. The Lower Levels, discounted goods and a recurring visit when he remains free connect across every account. That makes the choice relevant both to the shop’s stock and to the character storyline. He is therefore more than a seller: he is a wanted character with a recurring presence.

When does the butcher quest begin?

The first visit can happen as early as Day 14, or Day 5 when Skip Intro is used (Probably Stolen Game Wiki). Once the first visit has happened, he returns every seven days if he remains unreported, giving the butcher quest a repeat schedule.

For a player planning around the encounter, the confirmed timing points are the earliest stated first visit and the return interval. The stated timing gives the earliest arrival and recurring gap, rather than a fuller calendar of every possible visit. He may appear on different early days depending on whether Skip Intro is used, then can return on the seven-day cycle while free.

Entries How it is counted
Day 14Earliest stated first visit without Skip Intro
Day 5Earliest stated first visit with Skip Intro
Every 7 daysReturn interval while he remains free
450 CreditsReward for reporting him
500 CreditsCost of Sawyer’s Hunt the Butcher service
Six days laterTiming of the revenge sequence after reporting

What does the Butcher sell?

The Butcher sells discounted meat and scavenged goods, with the first visit carrying a small satchel, a crowbar and fresh meat (Probably Stolen Game Wiki, Indiatimes’ game guide). These are the specific goods for the encounter.

If he stays free, the recurring visit is associated with stolen meat sold at a discount. The Probably Stolen Game character page says he sells stolen meat every seven days, and the Probably Stolen Game Wiki fan site likewise describes discounted stolen meat on his return visits. The Probably Stolen butcher’s trade therefore has a stated first-visit selection and a recurring meat offer.

What changes when you report the Butcher?

Spoilers: click to expand

Reporting the Butcher pays 450 Credits and adds Security and Lower Levels points. The report also starts a revenge sequence six days later, and an Incident Slip joins the reporting rewards (Probably Stolen Game character page, Probably Stolen Game Wiki).

Reporting also starts a storyline that can lead to the Butcher coming after you. The Probably Stolen Game Wiki storyline page says he later leaves a cleaver and a note saying he is hunting you. The sequence matters when weighing the reward against the later hunt: the reported outcome includes both the Credits and reputation gains, and a retaliation storyline. These consequences are spoiler details, so consider them only if you want the result before making the choice.

How can the butcher quest hunt end?

Spoilers: click to expand

Sawyer’s Hunt the Butcher service can end the hunt for 500 Credits. The Probably Stolen Game character page gives the service name and price, and the Probably Stolen Game Wiki storyline page says the hunt can end when Sawyer’s crew visits the Butcher. Together, those details identify the cost and condition for ending the pursuit.

The service ends the hunt after the retaliation storyline begins. No additional steps or outcomes sit beyond buying the service and Sawyer’s crew visiting the Butcher, so those are the concrete details to keep in view. The butcher quest has a defined paid resolution, with a 500 Credit cost attached to Sawyer’s service. This section contains storyline spoilers about what follows a report.

Does cleaning the graffiti finish the butcher quest?

Spoilers: click to expand

Cleaning the graffiti does not finish the quest. Reporting the Butcher triggers a revenge storyline, and removing the graffiti does not complete it (Indiatimes’ game guide). That distinction matters if you are trying to understand whether the visible graffiti is the final task: cleaning it is separate from finishing the quest.

The revenge storyline is also described through the later hunt and the Butcher’s message. The Probably Stolen Game Wiki storyline page says he leaves a cleaver and a note declaring that he is hunting you. Read together, these details make the report’s consequences a sequence rather than a single immediate reward. The graffiti detail adds a specific quest clarification, while the hunt and note describe the later retaliation. These are spoilers for the character storyline.

What should you know about the Probably Stolen butcher?

The clearest way to read this encounter is as a choice between recurring trade and a report with a stated reward and storyline consequences. The non-spoiler details establish his Lower Levels identity, the discounted goods, the first-visit items, and the seven-day return interval if he remains free. Those points help explain why the encounter can matter beyond the first conversation.

The reporting route carries specific consequences: the 450 Credit reward, Security and Lower Levels points, an Incident Slip, and a later revenge storyline. A 500 Credit service can end the hunt afterwards. A player who wants to preserve the encounter’s surprise can use the trade and visit information alone; a player deciding with full storyline context can weigh the report, retaliation and service details together. The wanted-list criminals, including the Butcher, have expanded backstories (Steam announcement).

Which shop and customer pages connect to the Butcher?

The Butcher’s visit connects to several other shop topics covered in the guide. See Wanted Customers, Customers, and Security and Evidence for related pages. These links provide places to continue reading about customer encounters and reporting without adding further details to the Butcher storyline.

Gallery

Probably Stolen screenshot 1, Probably Stolen butcher
Probably Stolen butcher, screenshot 1
Probably Stolen screenshot 2, Probably Stolen butcher
Probably Stolen butcher, screenshot 2
Probably Stolen screenshot 3, Probably Stolen butcher
Probably Stolen butcher, screenshot 3

Frequently asked questions

Who is the Probably Stolen butcher?

He is a wanted man from the Lower Levels who sells meat and scavenged goods. He returns every seven days if you leave him unreported.

When does the Probably Stolen butcher first visit?

His first visit can be as early as Day 14, or Day 5 with Skip Intro. If he remains free, he returns every seven days.

What does the Butcher sell on his first visit?

His first visit includes a small satchel, a crowbar, and fresh meat at a discount. The character is also described as selling scavenged goods.

What do you get for reporting the Butcher?

Reporting him gives 450 Credits, Security and Lower Levels points, and an Incident Slip. The report also starts a retaliation storyline.

How can you end the Probably Stolen butcher hunt?

Sawyer’s Hunt the Butcher service can end the hunt for 500 Credits. The storyline description connects the end of the hunt to Sawyer’s crew visiting the Butcher.

Sources