Skip to content
Powered by Pagefind

Probably Stolen appraisal Guide

By the Probably Stolen Wiki editors

Updated

Probably Stolen appraisal works by inspecting a customer’s item, submitting an integer estimate, and receiving a rating based on how close that estimate is to the item’s base value. Rare goods should be appraised before you quote a price, and the published daily loop puts inspection before quoting.

Illustration for a Probably Stolen guide: Corked bottles resting on a wooden rack beside a brass fermenting vat; muted palette with one pale amber accent.
Illustration

How Probably Stolen appraisal works

The process begins with a customer’s item: inspect it with a Magnifying Glass, work out an estimate, and submit that integer for a rating. The Probably Stolen Game Wiki fan site says the rating measures how close the estimate is to the item’s true base value. Each rank accepts different grades, so the rating affects whether the estimate is accepted.

An accepted appraisal pays a rank based base fee plus a commission calculated from the estimate you submitted. An unacceptable estimate increases the customer’s impatience, and enough impatience makes the customer leave. That makes the estimate matter for both the appraisal outcome and the customer’s willingness to stay.

The daily loop places inspection before a price quote. The Navgame appraisal basics page also recommends appraising rare goods before quoting so you can avoid overpaying. That sequence gives the inspection a practical purpose: check what the customer has first, then decide what price to offer.

A useful way to follow the appraisal guide is to treat each customer item as a small sequence: inspect the details, decide whether the item needs a value estimate or an authenticity check, then submit the relevant result. The steps differ by item. Some goods are assessed by value, while other checks focus on whether an item is genuine or usable.

For hands, Plasma Cartridges, and Ribwiches, value starts from a base amount, then changes through fixed feature adjustments and a minimum value floor. The same base, adjustment and floor structure applies across those items. For cigarettes and food stamps, the relevant task is to check visible details for counterfeit signs and select the matching issue tag.

Entries How it is counted
Estimate formatSubmit an integer estimate
Estimate ratingCloseness to the true base value
Accepted estimateRank based base fee plus commission
Unacceptable estimateCustomer impatience increases
Wrong appraisal tagPayout can fall by about 80%

What tools and guides support appraisal?

The Magnifying Glass is the inspection tool named in the appraisal tips page: each customer item must be inspected with it before you submit an estimate. The Magnifying Glass item page gives you a related place to read about the tool, while the item conditions guide covers the condition details that matter when identifying goods.

The appraisal basics leave room for different inspection methods. Cigarettes are checked visually, while water is scanned with an Aquascan so its purity can be read and treated to match its grade. The Aquascan item page and water grades and purification guide are useful related pages for that water check.

A browser appraisal tool lets you inspect a random item, practice identifying its condition and value, or reveal the answer. That makes it suited to practicing the observation and estimate parts of the process before handling a customer’s item. The available practice actions cover both deciding on an answer and checking what the answer is.

The game features authentication of rare goods and selling them for profit, and rare items need proper appraisal to avoid overpaying (Steam store page). For a broader look at where appraisal fits into buying and setting prices, see the stolen goods guide and the pricing guide. These related topics connect inspection to the decision that follows it.

  • Inspect customer items with the Magnifying Glass and submit an integer estimate when the task calls for a value.
  • Use visual details to check cigarettes and food stamps for counterfeit signs, then choose the matching issue tag.
  • Scan water with an Aquascan to read purity, then treat it to match its grade.
  • Use the browser tool to practice identifying an item’s condition and value, or reveal the answer.

What appraisal changes

Appraisal changes the money you earn, the customer’s patience, and the price decisions that follow inspection. Accepted appraisals pay a base fee tied to rank and commission based on the submitted estimate. Customers also pay for valuations, so appraisal can bring in income when the shop has no stock.

A wrong appraisal tag can reduce the payout by about 80%. A tag therefore matters alongside the estimate: for cigarettes and food stamps, checking visible details and matching the issue tag is part of the appraisal task. The Appraisal Committee visits around day 8 in a community playthrough, and membership costs 255 credits on the hardest difficulty.

Ten perfect appraisals unlock the An Eye for Value achievement. That gives a clear target for players who want to build appraisal accuracy over time. The achievement does not come with a list of grade thresholds, so focus on careful inspection and on submitting estimates that match the item’s features.

Not every appraisal is a price calculation. Immunivax appraisal checks whether the injector is genuine and usable rather than pricing it. The guide to Immunivax injectors and the Immunivax assessment guide are relevant when that item is the one being checked.

Numbered detail What it refers to
About 80%Possible payout reduction for the wrong appraisal tag
Around day 8Reported Appraisal Committee visit in a community playthrough
255 creditsReported membership cost on the hardest difficulty
Ten perfect appraisalsRequirement for the An Eye for Value achievement
Integer estimateRequired format for an appraisal submission

What is our take on the appraisal guide?

Appraisal covers two related jobs: estimating an item’s value and checking whether it is authentic or usable. Value estimates are rated against the item’s base value, while some counterfeit checks use visible details and a matching issue tag. Immunivax appraisal checks authenticity and usability, so the right method depends on the item.

The clearest practical order is to inspect before making a price decision. The Magnifying Glass supports customer item inspections, and the Aquascan is the named tool for reading water purity. For items with a base value and feature adjustments, consider those features before submitting an estimate; for cigarettes and food stamps, use the visible details to choose the matching issue tag.

The appraisal process combines a potential income source with a customer patience risk. An accepted valuation pays a rank based fee and commission, while an unacceptable estimate raises impatience until the customer may leave. The appraisal practice tool gives you a way to rehearse item condition and value identification, and the achievement provides a stated goal of ten perfect appraisals.

A practical reading of the available guides is to keep the steps distinct: inspect the item, determine whether the task is valuation or authentication, then submit the relevant estimate or tag. The details supplied for each item type differ, so a single pricing method does not describe every appraisal. That distinction helps explain why item features, visible counterfeit signs, purity, or usability can each matter in different cases.

Gallery

Probably Stolen screenshot 1, Probably Stolen appraisal
Probably Stolen appraisal, screenshot 1
Probably Stolen screenshot 2, Probably Stolen appraisal
Probably Stolen appraisal, screenshot 2
Probably Stolen screenshot 3, Probably Stolen appraisal
Probably Stolen appraisal, screenshot 3

Frequently asked questions

How does Probably Stolen appraisal work?

Inspect the customer’s item with a Magnifying Glass, submit an integer estimate, and the game rates how close it is to the item’s true base value. Accepted appraisals pay a rank based fee plus commission, while an unacceptable estimate raises customer impatience.

What tool do I use for Probably Stolen appraisal?

The Magnifying Glass is the tool for inspecting each customer item before submitting an estimate. Water has a separate check: scan it with an Aquascan to read its purity, then treat it to match its grade.

Can Probably Stolen appraisal earn money when my shop has no stock?

Yes, appraisal customers pay for valuations, which can provide income even when the shop has no stock. Accepted appraisals also pay a rank based base fee and commission calculated from the estimate.

What happens if I submit a bad estimate in Probably Stolen appraisal?

An unacceptable estimate increases the customer’s impatience, and enough impatience makes them leave. The rating depends on how close the estimate is to the item’s true base value, with different grades accepted at different ranks.

How do I check cigarettes during appraisal?

Cigarettes are checked by visual inspection, and counterfeit checks for cigarettes use visible details and a matching issue tag. The exact visual criteria for identifying counterfeit cigarettes are not confirmed.

Does every Probably Stolen appraisal calculate an item’s price?

No, some appraisal checks focus on authenticity or usability instead of pricing. Immunivax appraisal checks whether the injector is genuine and usable.

Sources